Damon Weaver

Damon Weaver is a fifth grader, but he is well on his way to a career in journalism. Recently, he interviewed Joe Biden. This will make you smile. (via Big Shot Bob in Texas)

Comments

[DUKE]

THIS YOUNG MAN HAS SOMETHING GOING FOR HIM.NOT ONLY STAGE PRESENCE, BUT HE'S THE FIRST REPORTER I'VE EVER SEEN ASK A POLITICIAN A DIRECT QUESTION & GET A DIRECT ANSWER.

[Vagabond]

http://www.nytimes.com/2008/10/27/opinion/27reynolds.html?ref=opinion
Joe Biden is WRONG.

THE presidential campaign has taken a detour into a dispute over the constitutional status of the vice presidency. It all started when Sarah Palin asserted in her debate with Joe Biden that the vice president should play an important role in the legislative branch.

Ms. Palin has been roundly mocked for her claim. But she was probably right.

Article I of the Constitution, which describes the authority of the legislative branch, says that “the vice president of the United States shall be president of the Senate, but shall have no vote, unless they be equally divided.” Aside from the job of replacing a president who dies or is unable to serve, the only vice presidential duties that are spelled out in the Constitution are legislative in character.

But if the vice president is a legislative official, then the exercise of executive power by the vice president raises important constitutional questions related to the separation of powers. The Supreme Court has held on more than one occasion that legislative officials cannot exercise executive power. The Court would likely dub this a “political question” that is beyond its purview, but Congress is empowered to remedy this sort of thing by legislation.

And Congress should do just that: pass a law to prohibit the vice president from exercising executive power. Extensive vice presidential involvement in the executive branch — the role enjoyed by Dick Cheney and Al Gore — is not only unconstitutional, but also a bad idea.

The most important function of a vice president is to serve as a spare president. Using the spare president in the ordinary course of business is as unwise as driving on one’s spare tire. Spares should be kept pristine, for when they are really needed.

If the president resigns or is removed from office, a vice president who has been involved in the activities of the executive branch is also likely to be at risk for impeachment. Just as important, a vice president who is enmeshed in the affairs of the president cannot offer a fresh start for the executive branch.

The joke may turn out to be on Mr. Biden, who upbraided Ms. Palin for her reading of the Constitution. Presumably Mr. Biden thinks Barack Obama chose him for the same reason that George W. Bush chose Mr. Cheney, as a way of making up for a lack of experience in foreign affairs. Mr. Bush’s choice led him to rely on Mr. Cheney in ways that were unprecedented — and unconstitutional.

Let’s hope Mr. Obama disappoints Mr. Biden. The Constitution and the best interests of the country suggest that the best place for the vice president is in the Senate.

By: Glenn Harlan Reynolds, professor of law at the University of Tennessee.

[Lee]

I love Damon.